Skip to content
Centre for Inquiry Canada

Centre for Inquiry Canada

Your humanist community for scientific, skeptical, secular, and rational inquiry

  • About
    • About CFIC
    • What Is CFIC?
      • Mission, Vision, & Values
      • Centre for Inquiry Globally
      • Why We Need CFIC
      • History
    • Areas of Focus
      • Secularism
      • Scientific Skepticism
      • Critical Thinking
      • Building Community
    • Our Structure
      • Governance of CFIC
      • CFIC Bylaws
      • Branches
    • Contact
    • Privacy Statement
  • Media
    • Critical Links Newsletter
    • Podcast for Inquiry
    • Search Archives
    • Videos
    • Cost of Religion Report
  • Get Involved
    • Join Us
    • Calendar of Events
    • Find a Local Branch
      • Victoria
      • Regina
      • Saskatoon
      • Winnipeg
      • Ottawa
      • Toronto
      • Montreal
      • Halifax
      • Virtual Branch
    • Volunteer
    • Mailing List
  • Donate
    • Donate to CFIC
    • CanadaHelps
    • PayPal
    • Interac Transfer
  • Become a Member
  • Toggle search form

Keith’s Conundrums: Hilbert’s Hotel

Posted on July 30, 2020July 30, 2020 By Critical Links 2 Comments on Keith’s Conundrums: Hilbert’s Hotel

By Keith Douglas

To recap from last time, Democritus’ cone, as it is called, can be used (as have many of the conundrums) to reflect on idealizations, the relationship between math and the world, etc. I especially like it for the latter, because it shows actually that much of what we learned in math classes (particularly quantitative geometry and trigonometry) was actually protophysics.

Something new, then.

Hilbert’s Hotel

Many summers I like to take trips to this conference or that, to talk to people working on familiar yet different problems and interests, to see the sights and enjoy some new foods. This summer, since I’m not likely to go very far for the reasons you might sadly realize, I’m thinking of a certain special hotelier who has been important to me in the past, a Mr. D. Hilbert.

It turns out he was once trying to accommodate a large number of guests in his wondrous facility (try the vegetable stew!). Normally he puts guests sequentially into available rooms as they arrive: the first in the first room, the second in the second, and so on. But once, so many guests arrived that the line at the desk was ended by a guy whose ticker-tape serve number read “omega + 1.”

Nevertheless, Mr. Hilbert wanted the business of all these people. Since there were so many, he offered a massive discount to all. He put them all into rooms, even offering a spare room between each pair of guests, and charged them the reciprocal of their room number in dollars per night.

Hilbert’s hotel has rooms starting at 1 and going up from there. Ever since that wonderful night of backgammon, chess, and those little crackers with salmon (not to mention Twister), Mr. Hilbert has been a very rich man indeed. I understand he’s looking to retire and put his sizable fortune into musical performances, focusing on symmetry of exposition and pieces which require diophantine analysis to play. My favourite musicians could use the money! I hope a good amount goes to them! (But can one play a diophantine piece on the cello? Hmmmm!)

(Your mission is to comment on my admittedly fanciful tale of Mr. Hilbert, including to guess his given name, which oddly I am not sure I remember.)

Think Check

Post navigation

Previous Post: Racism in Canada
Next Post: September 2020 News and Events

Comments (2) on “Keith’s Conundrums: Hilbert’s Hotel”

  1. peter hoffman says:
    July 31, 2020 at 6:20 am

    What a selfish guy, that hotelier. Almost as bad as Mass Murderer donald. He should have charged them, in $CDN of course, the sum of 1 over the squares of their room numbers.
    Peter

  2. Pingback: Keith’s Conundrums: Following a Contradiction – Centre for Inquiry Canada

Comments are closed.

Donate via PayPal
Donate via Interac
Donate via CanadaHelps

Categories

a4a Announcement assistance for apostates Blasphemy Laws Blasphemy Laws CFI Community CFIC Volunteers Climate Change Cost of Religion critical links critical thinking Critical Thinking Week Debate Education Educational Material environment Event Give to CFIC governance health humanism Human Rights Information International Human Rights Living without Religion Media Advisory Medicine philosophy podcast Policy Press Release pseudoscience Quick Links quicklinks Science ScienceChek Science Literacy Secular Check Secularism Secularism in Schools Secular Rescue skeptics slider Think Check volunteer

View Full Calendar

CFI Canada is a CRA-Registered Educational Charity
Charitable Registration Number: 83364 2614 RR0001

Privacy Statement

Copyright © 2025 Centre for Inquiry Canada.

Powered by PressBook WordPress theme