Skip to content
Centre for Inquiry Canada

Centre for Inquiry Canada

Your humanist community for scientific, skeptical, secular, and rational inquiry

  • About
    • About CFIC
    • What Is CFIC?
      • Mission, Vision, & Values
      • Centre for Inquiry Globally
      • Why We Need CFIC
      • History
    • Areas of Focus
      • Secularism
      • Scientific Skepticism
      • Critical Thinking
      • Building Community
    • Our Structure
      • Governance of CFIC
      • CFIC Bylaws
      • Branches
    • Contact
    • Privacy Statement
  • Media
    • Critical Links Newsletter
    • Podcast for Inquiry
    • Search Archives
    • Videos
    • Cost of Religion Report
  • Get Involved
    • Join Us
    • Calendar of Events
    • Find a Local Branch
      • Victoria
      • Regina
      • Saskatoon
      • Winnipeg
      • Ottawa
      • Toronto
      • Montreal
      • Halifax
      • Virtual Branch
    • Volunteer
    • Mailing List
  • Donate
    • Donate to CFIC
    • CanadaHelps
    • PayPal
    • Interac Transfer
  • Become a Member
  • Toggle search form

Barry’s Powerbook

Posted on April 29, 2019May 8, 2019 By E Pictetus
Years ago, I knew a computer programmer by the name of Barry. At the time, he was very fond of a particular PowerBook Duo. He took it on business trips around the world. From time to time a key would break, or a hinge would snap, and he would replace or repair the part. Eventually, he figured he’d replaced every part at least once.
He affectionately referred to it as still the same computer, saying that at any one time there were parts from the previous version of the machine, stretching back to when he first bought it however many years previous
Was Barry right?
If you are disinclined to think that he actually had the same computer the whole time, I encourage you to think about why you think so. But keep in mind that much seems to be the same of us. You have likely next to no atoms from your original stock, however defined (e.g., you at birth, you at conception, etc.). On the other hand, if you agree that Barry kept the same computer all those years, try to think through what might underlie that continuity, and again apply the same reasoning to us.
Finally, as an interesting twist on a more personal note, my father, now in his mid-70s, has a tiny amount of scar tissue on his neck. This is a result from an injury he suffered as a teenager. So there is a very bizarre form of continuity over time here for sure!
Fields to consider: metaphysics of persistence and identity; mereology; legal responsibility and powers-of-attorney; biochemistry.
Announcement

Post navigation

Previous Post: Kids for Inquiry held during Skepticamp 2019
Next Post: Bald man with no hair?
Donate via PayPal
Donate via Interac
Donate via CanadaHelps

Categories

a4a Announcement assistance for apostates Blasphemy Laws Blasphemy Laws CFI Community CFIC Volunteers Climate Change Cost of Religion critical links critical thinking Critical Thinking Week Debate Education Educational Material environment Event Give to CFIC governance health humanism Human Rights Information International Human Rights Living without Religion Media Advisory Medicine philosophy podcast Policy Press Release pseudoscience Quick Links quicklinks Science ScienceChek Science Literacy Secular Check Secularism Secularism in Schools Secular Rescue skeptics slider Think Check volunteer

View Full Calendar

CFI Canada is a CRA-Registered Educational Charity
Charitable Registration Number: 83364 2614 RR0001

Privacy Statement

Copyright © 2025 Centre for Inquiry Canada.

Powered by PressBook WordPress theme