Commission-Based Financial Advisors: What’s (Left) in Your Wallet?
By Todd De Ryck & Brent Sanderson
Sunday, December 6 at 8 p.m. (ET)
For decades, investors have been led to believe that they are receiving objective, professional advice from their financial advisor. Far too commonly however, financial advisors and the firms that they work for are rife with conflicts of interest, perpetuate long disproven investing myths, and profit handsomely from unnecessarily high fees and commissions on high-cost investment products, all at the expense of their clients’ financial well-being. It is estimated that the compounded effect of the unjustifiably high fees charged by the wealth management industry has cost North American retail investors more than $2 trillion in forgone wealth over the 1991 through 2020 period alone. Until recently, the traditional wealth management industry has evaded accountability for failing to put their clients’ interests at the center of the advice they give. The good news however, is that there may never have been a better time in history than today to be an average investor. After exposing the worst of the wealth management industry’s shortcomings, your host will share alternatives to this predatory business model that you can use in order to better ensure your own future financial security.

Over a nearly 30-year career in business, Brent Sanderson held positions in accounting and finance; senior positions in energy market research, analysis and risk management; as well as regulatory affairs and energy policy. He appeared on numerous occasions as an expert witness at public hearings before regulatory tribunals including the Manitoba Public Utilities Board and the Canada Energy Regulator (formerly the National Energy Board). He has been a featured speaker at a number of international energy risk management conferences. His work has been profiled in international risk management publications. He also served as a university guest lecturer for many years, covering global energy markets and management in the energy industry. He holds a bachelor’s degree in business, with great distinction, from Athabasca University. He also holds the professional designation of Certified Energy Risk Professional with the Global Association of Risk Professionals.
Keith’s Conundrums: November 2026
This month we have a recap, another personal note / digression and the new material.
Recap
Last time I shared a brief partial review of a 20-year-old book in the philosophy of science. I’ve received as yet no commentary or questions on this. I also did not get any reactions to celebrating Mole Day. As I write this, this holiday has yet to happen still, so perhaps I should be patient.
Digression
November marks my 50th birthday. (Yikes!) Have a happy-my-birthday everyone. If you want to give me a present, support in whatever way you can (even if just “morally”) public education – I have benefited greatly from this, including at second and third hand. If you want to give another one, write back to me with a suggestion for the next column. 😊
What’s New
This month’s column is about the so-called Pinocchio Paradox. This is a fun little variation on the classic liar (and likely has some of the same challenges to resolve) and was new to me until quite recently. I’ll state one version of the paradox, analyze it and riff on a few of the themes and ideas that come up. As usual, your mission, dear reader, is to see what you think and my job is merely provocation – of a good kind, I hope.
Many of us have read or seen classic versions of the fairy tale, Pinocchio or similar. I remember as a child seeing the Disney version though I have no clear sense when or why. The story revolves around the adventures of a wooden doll, ventriloquist’s dummy or mannikin come to life through magic, who also has the unusual trait of having his nose grow whenever he tells a falsehood. He also is famous for wanting to be “a real boy”. For purposes of the present column there are only two important aspects of this fable. One is that the creature in question is the result of magic; the other is the nose bit.
So, with that in mind, consider the sentence: “My nose will grow if I state this.”
An obvious falsehood for myself and I trust all of my readers. However, then consider Pinocchio saying it. If he’s telling the truth, then “My nose will grow if I state this.” is true, and hence his nose will grow. But his nose should only grow if he’s telling a falsehood, so woops, that’s not right. Similarly, if he’s telling a falsehood, his nose should grow, because he’s telling a falsehood. But then his nose did grow, so that’s not right either.
As the reader can see, this looks like a version of the liar paradox. (“I am lying.”)
However, it is a paradox that seems to have consequences beyond the truth or falsehood of statements – namely, what happens in the world. Here are several possible ways out of this problem.
First is to deny that Pinocchio as described can exist. Maybe the situation is like the barber paradox – where the village that supposedly has a barber that shaves all and only those who don’t shave themselves just cannot exist. However, how would one experience trying to construct the doll? There are philosophers who think one can experience a logical contradiction in various ways; I’m sort of dubious. On the other hand, that there’s a “superstition” against them (Wittgenstein and Priest, for example) seems also wrong. (Priest thinks some of them are true; Wittgenstein thinks they are just epistemic “no-operations”.)
Second, one could deny that telling a falsehood to make a nose grow is implausible for other reasons – even with magic. Why? It would turn Pinocchio into an oracle – just get him to utter anything. Even if he doesn’t have access to that part of himself until the nose grows, he then becomes a way to determine the truth of any statement – as written.
On the other hand, there’s another way to describe Pinocchio’s unusual nose that is sometimes heard: his nose grows when he lies. In which case, there’s seemingly no paradox at first glance. Delving into this prompts a discussion of what lying is. At first blush, a lie is a knowing statement of a falsehood. It doesn’t have to be for gain, but one has to be (in some sense) caring that one has uttered one – otherwise one is a bullshitter (sensu Frankfurt), rather than a liar. This can be so even for good motives (unless one is a Kantian or perhaps even just Kant) – the so-called “white lies” are in this category.
But then there’s a further problem. Pinocchio or someone else can run this analysis (telling him if he can’t do it himself) and then because he knows he’s stating something true or false, he cannot claim innocence (like he might have earlier) and we seem to be back where we started.
Changing tack, slightly. When I first encountered this, I thought of Raymond Smullyan’s little book (which I want to eventually chase down at the used book sellers) that I read as an undergraduate – Forever Undecided: A Puzzle Guide to Goedel. In it we read discussions of sentences like: “The reader of this column cannot believe this sentence even though he knows it to be true.” I couldn’t figure out how to make this sort of pseudo-epistemic logic get any purchase on the Pinocchio Paradox – but maybe someone else can see what I think I saw and run with it better.
Another possibility is to use a third truth value – but that might subject Pinocchio to the revenge liar problem. Nevertheless, I invite the reader to consider the difference between Pinocchio’s nose growing when he states something that is not true, vs. stating something that is false. What if it is the latter? Then “My nose will grow.” could be taken as neither true nor false, so he’s off the hook and the nose stays as is.
There’s another possibility family – where I will leave the column for today – which is that one has to use one of the many techniques (all of which are much too complicated) to solve the liar paradox and apply it here directly.
¹ If you think I’m mistaken about the nose, precisely, hold that thought! You’re on to part of the puzzle.
Pinocchio Old Wooden Marionette Toy, photo by Boskoboca, via Dreamstime
“It’s Only Waste if We Waste it”. Spent Nuclear Fuel or “Nuclear Waste” is a Valuable Resource.
By Todd De Ryck
Here is a post I wrote in December, 2025: “It’s only waste if we waste it“.

Cal Doucette, Director, Engineering with ARC Clean Technology in New Brunswick will conduct a webinar about their company, their sodium fast nuclear reactor, their experience completing two stages of the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission’s (CNSC) pre licensing vendor design review and will discuss why spent nuclear fuel, or “nuclear waste” is actually a valuable resource.

Their nuclear reactor is based on the EBR II (Experimental Breeder Reactor II), which operated for 30 years at Idaho National Labs. Here is a 20 minute film “Making a Contribution: The Story of EBR-II“. Here is an eight-minute segment from the pro-nuclear documentary “Pandora’s Promise” specifically about the EBR II “The Integral Fast Reactor“.
Here is the full version of “Pandora’s Promise,” which made its debut on CNN in November 2013: https://youtu.be/YPIHWrRuHlE?si=xiqdcgjstIs_7zON.
Here are two books related to the technical details of this reactor and its potential: “Plentiful Energy” and “Prescription for the Planet“.
Cal Doucette
Director, Engineering, ARC Clean Technology
Cal Doucette has over 30 years of engineering experience in the petrochemical, wood products, air pollution control, solvent recycling, telecommunications, consulting engineering, and nuclear industries. He has been a plant manager, multidisciplinary project manager, lead engineer, and president of a privately owned consulting engineering firm.
Cal served as a design engineering section head and system responsible operations specialist with Canadian Nuclear Laboratories (CNL). He was also the project manager for emergency core cooling strainer installations, lead engineer for the NRU vessel leak repair project and responsible for the processing of legacy liquid waste through the CNL liquid waste immobilization system. Cal holds a Bachelor of Chemical Engineering degree from McGill University.
Recovering from Religion Starting in Ottawa with CFIC
Recovering from Religion (RfR) plans to establish permanent chapters in Canada, and the Centre for Inquiry Canada (CFIC) is pleased to announce that we’ll be cooperating with them to establish their first in-person meetings in Ottawa this fall. CFIC’s role will be to help set up and promote their meetings, as well as recruit local volunteer facilitators.
Founded in 2009 by psychologist and author Dr. Darrel Ray, RfR provides support to people who have experienced trauma as a result of their religious upbringing or who are struggling with themselves, their families, or loved ones as they consider leaving their religion. In addition to in-person meetings, primarily in the United States and Australia, RfR offers global virtual meetings and a 24-hour support line. If you’re interested in training to become a volunteer Support Group Leader in Ottawa or wherever you are, you can contact RfR directly through their website.
We already have two volunteers in Ottawa ready to start training, and we’ll be holding a Zoom meeting for other potential volunteers later in September. If the Ottawa pilot goes as well as expected, CFIC and RfR hope to establish chapters in other Canadian cities in the future.
Earn Free CFIC Membership by Volunteering
Volunteering for Centre for Inquiry Canada (CFIC) helps keep critical thinking, science, secularism, and human rights alive in your community.
CFIC requires our volunteers to become a CFIC member. The annual fee is usually $45 CAD for an individual or $60 for a household, but because of our charitable status, all memberships and donations over $25 CAD are eligible for a CRA tax receipt.
For those whose circumstances make paying the membership fee financially challenging, we offer “earned memberships” for volunteers who commit to contributing a minimum of only 4 hours per month. Volunteering for CFIC can take many forms:
- Co-host or act as a helper for an upcoming virtual or in-person event.
- Propose, plan, or run a new event of your own.
- Arrange for CFIC to participate in an activist march, protest or public campaign, such as our ongoing fight to eliminate public funding for religious school boards in Saskatchewan, Ontario and Alberta.
- Write articles for Critical Links, help with data analysis, fundraising, offer to be an assistant webmaster, or offer your talents in other ways.
- Take on a leadership role at the branch or national level.
Fill in the Volunteer Application Form, and our team will be in touch to discuss ways that you can make a difference. You can also become part of CFIC’s new Volunteer Academy, where we’ll provide ongoing training and involvement.


