Spoon Bending and Higher Learning
The University of Alberta’s Pediatric Integrative Medicine Rounds had scheduled a session entitled “Spoon Bending and the Power of the Mind” for June 28th but soon cancelled it after Timothy Caulfield, a professor of health law and science policy at the University, called them out by tweeting an image of the poster advertising the event. After the tweet was widely circulated, garnering ridicule and disbelief, the presenters withdrew the session. Billed as an “experimental workshop” teaching “a guided meditation/energy transfer technique which will have most participants bending cutlery using the power of their minds”, Caulfield at first thought it was a magic show. He soon realized it was no joke and saw that other topics such as “the power of positivity, manifesting, and some quantum physics experiments” were to be included. An odd disclaimer also stated that the workshop was “experimental” and “will not be a scientific evaluation of the process”. Unscientific it certainly would have been, as any skeptic knows.
Spoon bending, popularized in the 70s by Uri Geller and famously debunked by James Randi on live TV over 40 years ago, is easy for anyone but it’s not done with the mind. Several ways to perform this trick are easily found online. Since spoon bending is almost a poster-child for the skeptical movement, being so easy to explain and so widely understood, the incident must have been deeply embarrassing for the University of Alberta.
The presenter was to be Anastasia Kutt, an Edmonton “energy healer” and an education coordinator and for the CARE (Complementary and Alternative Research and Education) programme. Her website describes her as a “reiki specialist” who is capable of “removing issues and stress from your energetic field, to bring it into balance and its original state of good health.” Reiki is another pseudoscience in which “energy fields are manipulated”. For these reasons the CARE programme deserves scrutiny and serious debate about its place in academia.
Caulfield is not alone in being concerned that “these kinds of programs legitimize the pseudo-science.” They also waste money on “therapies” that have failed the evidence test and have no place in university. In an alarming trend, however, several medical schools have been being infiltrated by “alternative medicine” institutes and schools masquerading as science. The University of Toronto has a Center for Integrative Medicine and there are many more in the US. It must be getting more and more difficult for medical students to tell the difference between evidence-based medicine and quackery when they are peddled snake oil by their own institution.
- US to tighten rules on homeopathic “medicines”
- Timothy Caulfield coming to Ottawa
- Unfriending the Future: Motivated Empathy in Science and Political Advocacy
- Support Secularism in British Columbia
- Public Promotion of Religion In Quebec Schools
- 20140815_G JerryCoyne_0755 (Large)
- Cupping: Premier pseudoscience for the Games of the XXXI Olympiad
- 2015/2016 Flu Shot is a Good Idea
- History of Centre for Inquiry Canada
- Another Pediatric Death by World View
- Founders of Centre for Inquiry Canada
- History and Mandate
- A Call for Justice
- Press Centre
- CFI Canada Board of Directors
- CFIC’s Ethical Perspectives
- CFI Canada Student Campus Groups
- Physician-Assisted Death
- Assisted Dying in Canada: Where Do We Go From Here
- CFIDiscourse #2: On Pseudo-skepticism and the Vice of Open-Mindedness
- Become a CFI Canada Student Affiliate
- Is God a Figment of our Imagination?
- Not Over Yet! Humanists Should Speak out on the Right to Die with Dignity
- Secular Human Rights Campaigns
- CFI to file human rights complaint alleging discrimination by Pattison Outdoor in Vancouver
- Winnipeg Bus Shelter Ads Highlight Human Rights Violations
- International Human Rights
- CFIC Discourse
- CFIC’s founding principles
- Canada’s Standing Committee on Health (HESA): Report 13
- Secular Humanists and Atheists Grieve With the Nation
- HUMAN RIGHTS
- Pro-Vaccination Art
- Charlie Hebdo and the Question of Blasphemy
- International Women’s Day
- From the Cradle to the Grave
- CFI Canada Condemns All Faith-Based Violence
- 2018 Message from the Chair of the Board of Directors
- Are Organized Religions a Possible Public Health Hazard “Vector”? Apparently we have our job to do…
- Canada’s Blasphemous Libel Law
- Pearle and JT
- Secular, Humanist and Freethought Links
- 2016 CFIC AGM and Elections Notice
- Will You Make a Commitment to Reason and Science Today?