Are Organized Religions a Possible Public Health Hazard “Vector”? Apparently we have our job to do…
During CFI Canada’s monitoring of public health concerns such as anti-vaccination proponents, we often encounter pseudo-scientific claims and fears from people who either ignore or don’t understand the science behind vaccination and immunization. However, we’ve lately also noticed an increase in the troubling incursion of religion in this area of public health and healthcare.
Study #3 Measles in Canada 2015
On February 6, 2015 CBC posted a report that Canada had seen a sixth case confirmed. We have provided below a selection of media sources, commentary and information relating to media coverage. A feature which stands out in the Allan Maki’s Globe and Mail article from 2014 is the following details:
In the Netherlands, the most recent run of measles began in the country’s designated Bible Belt, an area occupied by conservative Protestants who refuse to vaccinate their children. That belief allowed the disease to go on a rampage, infecting more than 2,000 people with at least one death connected to the outbreak.
In Southern Alberta, it was a student who spread the disease after a visit to the Netherlands. The importation resulted in 42 confirmed cases in southern Alberta before the outbreak was declared over. As for the Fraser Valley and its 353 cases, it began with two students at a Christian school in Chilliwack, B.C.
CBC’s April 2014 story regarding measles is very instructive
It’s an inescapable reality: As long as measles is infecting children in other parts of the world, Canada is going to have occasional outbreaks. The same is true in the United States, but public health officials there typically have managed to more quickly extinguish spread of the virus when it comes from abroad.
….the largest outbreak the U.S. has experienced in nearly two decades occurred in an Orthodox Jewish community in Brooklyn, N.Y., last year. Total cases: 58. Indeed most measles outbreaks south of the border are far smaller, coming in at under two dozen cases, and many times fewer than a handful.
…..But when there are more unvaccinated children — or adults — transmission can go on for weeks, as it has in the Fraser Valley outbreak. There spread has emanated from a religious school — kindergarten to Grade 12 — affiliated with a church that opposes vaccination.
Repeatedly in Canadian coverage of measles outbreaks, connections to religious schools and communities appears to be a common factor.
Study #2 Measles Outbreak in Texas – August 2013
In August of 2013, a measles outbreak in Fort Worth Texas centred on a “megachurch” and resulted in Texas’ Department of State Health Services issuing a health alert. The Church, which had previously circulated anti-vaccination messages, ended up providing free vaccination clinics. 10 cases of measles are identified in this case. Related media links and commentary:
As recently as February 6, 2015, experts indicate that they expect a measles outbreak in Texas ( http://www.click2houston.com/news/experts-say-texas-likely-to-see-measles-outbreak/31140662); In this story, it is claimed that the vaccination rate in Texas is 92.7% but also reveals how many children are left vulnerable to life-threatening illness – 40,000. With a 90% infection rate, the potential number of cases in Texas is 36,000. With a mortality rate of 1 in 1000, the potential number of preventable infant deaths is 36.
Detailed information regarding measles in the US may be found here: http://pediatrics.about.com/od/measles/a/measles-outbreaks.htm including significant reference to an outbreak at Disneyland (California). Noteworthy is the statistic reported that the US saw a record low number of cases in 2004 at only 37 cases. A single visitor to the Texas megachurch in 2013 resulted in between 10 and 25 cases.
Study # 1 Vaccinations and the Catholic Church
Well the media did a great job in making the news rather than reporting it. I used two examples of issues where a moral lens needs to be used when dealing with such topics. I repeat, they were examples. There was no mention to open anything up as the Star would suggest. But let's be clear you have your job to do and I have mine which [is] to examine what we do in a faith guided morality.
- Vaccine records – Who’s responsible?
- Support Secularism in British Columbia
- Pro-Vaccination Art
- Winnipeg Bus Shelter Ads Highlight Human Rights Violations
- 2015/2016 Flu Shot is a Good Idea
- Another Pediatric Death by World View
- Secular Human Rights Campaigns
- CFI Condemns Murders at Charlie Hebdo
- CFIC Condemns Superstition-based Violence
- From the Cradle to the Grave
- Timothy Caulfield coming to Ottawa
- Canada’s Office of Religious Freedom
- 2018 Message from the Chair of the Board of Directors
- Crisis in Nepal: What can we do?
- Raif Badawi
- HUMAN RIGHTS
- Canada’s Blasphemous Libel Law
- Not Over Yet! Humanists Should Speak out on the Right to Die with Dignity
- Iceland Removes Blasphemy Law!
- US to tighten rules on homeopathic “medicines”
- Canada’s Standing Committee on Health (HESA): Report 13
- Press Centre
- Charlie Hebdo and the Question of Blasphemy
- Policy Statements
- Assisted Dying in Canada: Where Do We Go From Here
- Is it Science?
- Governance Documents
- Supreme Court Decision
- Public Promotion of Religion In Quebec Schools
- CFIC Discourse
- A Call for Justice
- Atheist Bloggers Risking Their Lives
- Spoon Bending and Higher Learning
- Spring is late – deadline extended for the Colouring Contest
- CFI Canada Student Campus Groups
- Secular, Humanist and Freethought Links
- History and Mandate
- CFIC Bylaws
- How To Help
- Sign, Sign, Everywhere a Sign
- Against Quebec’s Bill C21
- Who is CFIC, and what do we do?
- Election Process
- CFIDiscourse #2: On Pseudo-skepticism and the Vice of Open-Mindedness
- Welcome to the Centre for Inquiry
- 2016 CFIC AGM and Elections Notice
- CFI Canada Board of Directors
- Grandmother Fish
- CFI Canada 2014: Moving Forward
- Canada is Repealing its Blasphemy Law
- CFI Canada Condemns All Faith-Based Violence
- CFIC Logo Designs
- International Women’s Day
- Update on Parliamentary Petition e-382 calling for the elimnation of Canada’s anti-blasphemy law