2015/2016 Flu Shot is a Good Idea
For the first time, Canada is providing flu vaccines providing protection against four strains of the virus. Previous versions had only three strains. Our 2015 flu shot protects against:
- A/California/7/2009 (H1N1)pdm09-like virus
- A/Switzerland/9715293/2013 (H3N2)-like virus
- B/Phuket/3073/2013-like virus
- B strain – a B/Brisbane/60/2008-like virus
By most accounts the flu vaccine for 2015/2016 is not as efficacious as hoped, but getting it is still better than not getting it. Early data suggests that the vaccine effectiveness (VE) will be around 40-50%. Expressed as a percentage, VE represents the reduction in the risk that a person will need to visit a hospital or doctor’s office because of the flu. The CDC (Centers for Disease Control) is reporting an overall VE of 23% for North America. Even if the VE turns out to be on the low side it still means that 23% fewer of us will need medical care because of the flu and that’s nothing to sneeze at. According to Health Canada, seasonal flu results in approximately 12,200 hospitalizations and 3,500 deaths in our country every year. A 23% reduction means over 800 lives saved and thousands more avoiding the emergency room.
For some reason a January 2015 news item with misleading headlines about the low VE of the 2014 vaccine has been circulating again, perhaps in an effort to discredit the 2015 shot. One headline implied that the 2014 vaccine made it “more likely” that you would get the flu. What they should have said was that it was slightly less effective than the previous year’s formulation, not less effective than going vaccine-free. One of the most reported studies found that the VE for one of the 2014 flu vaccines offered in Canada was 69% if you had not had the vaccine in 2013 but only 65% if you had been vaccinated for both years. In other words, it was slightly more likely that you would get the flu in 2014 if you had vaccinations two years in a row, but the risk reduction was still 65% over no vaccine at all. So either way, you were much better off getting the shot in 2014.
Official reports of the 2014/2015 vaccine’s VE varied widely across North America. Since the strains to be included in the vaccine are chosen months ahead of the flu season, sometimes there is a mismatch between the vaccine strains and the ones that end up circulating in Canada, varying from region to region. Occasionally the strains mutate enough that the effectiveness of the vaccine is lessened. Health Canada also attributes some of the overall VE drop to a problem with stability of the A/California H1N1 vaccine strain when exposed to temperature fluctuations. This happened mostly in California where the vaccines were subjected to heat that rendered them less effective. The National Advisory Committee on Immunizations concluded that this is unlikely to be a problem in Canada because we have requirements for the maintenance of proper temperatures at all times. Monitoring devices or carrier logs are required to provide evidence that proper conditions were maintained.
Along with handwashing and plumbing, vaccines are among the safest, most important medical advances of all time and they are offered free or almost free to all Canadians. We should take full advantage of it.
Blythe Nilson, CFIC Science Chair
- Health Canada: http://www.phac-aspc.gc.ca/naci-ccni/flu-2015-grippe-eng.php#i1
- CDC 2015-2016 Flu Vaccines: http://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/season/flu-season-2015-2016.htm
- CDC Vaccine FAQ: http://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/qa/vaccineeffect.htm
- U. Manitoba Report: http://www.cidrap.umn.edu/news-perspective/2014/11/study-adds-more-data-effects-consecutive-year-flu-shots
- Pro-Vaccination Art
- Are Organized Religions a Possible Public Health Hazard “Vector”? Apparently we have our job to do…
- From the Cradle to the Grave
- Canada’s Standing Committee on Health (HESA): Report 13
- Timothy Caulfield coming to Ottawa
- CFIDiscourse #2: On Pseudo-skepticism and the Vice of Open-Mindedness
- Secular, Humanist and Freethought Links
- CFI Condemns Murders at Charlie Hebdo
- Will You Make a Commitment to Reason and Science Today?
- James Randi in Toronto!
- Spoon Bending and Higher Learning
- CFI Canada Student Campus Groups
- New CFIC Logo Designs
- Exposing the harmful pseudoscience of “alternative medicine”
- STAND UP FOR SCIENCE
- International Women’s Day
- Raif Badawi
- Supreme Court Decision
- Assisted Dying in Canada: Where Do We Go From Here
- A Call for Justice
- Governance Documents
- Iceland Removes Blasphemy Law!
- Canada’s Blasphemous Libel Law
- Crisis in Nepal: What can we do?
- Who is CFIC, and what do we do?
- Canada’s Office of Religious Freedom
- CFIC Condemns Superstition-based Violence
- Public Promotion of Religion In Quebec Schools
- Another Pediatric Death by World View
- Atheist Bloggers Risking Their Lives
- Become a CFI Canada Student Affiliate
- Policy Statements
- Catholic School Board Breaking the Law, Complaint Alleges
- Thanks for supporting CFI Canada
- CFI condemns attacks on religious groups in Egypt
- CFIC Library needs your help!
- Spring is late – deadline extended for the Colouring Contest
- CFI Manitoba
- Press Centre
- Not Over Yet! Humanists Should Speak out on the Right to Die with Dignity
- HUMAN RIGHTS
- Grandmother Fish
- CFI Canada 2014: Moving Forward
- CFI Canada 2014: Moving Forward
- Secular Humanists and Atheists Grieve With the Nation
- Press Release – Deny Law School Accreditation to Anti-Gay University
- Charlie Hebdo and the Question of Blasphemy
- Canada Deserves Better Than Pope John Paul II Day
- CFI Canada at the Office of Religious Freedom’s EAC
- Carl Sagan Day 2014 at CFI Canada!
- Canada to Uganda – CFI pushes gay rights against religious bigotry
- CFI Membership
- Secular Community Services
- Ask the “religion experts” – a secular humanist perspective
- Welcome to the Centre for Inquiry
- Contact Us